
You know the story by now. The NFL and its vengeful deities cruelly forced the Pats from the playoffs after a flat-out gutsy 11 win season. Pats fans had the highest of hopes coming into the season, after falling just 30 seconds short of the first 19-0 season in NFL history. Yet after losing Tom Brady 7 minutes into the season after a devastating blow to the knee from Kansas City Chiefs safety Bernard F. Pollard, most Pats fans immediately wrote off their team for dead and prepared for 2009. We had reached the point where nothing less than a fourth Super Bowl championship would relieve our football appetite, a perspective that put us on par with, dare I say, the abominable New York Yankee fans. With Brady out of the picture, our chance at a title was blown and a season initially filled with hope and expectation plummeted into the abyss. We were expected to pin these impossible expectations onto a quarterback who had not started a game since Clinton was in office? A 7 win team, maybe. The Lost Season. We’ll be back next year.
In the weeks following Brady’s injury, Bill Belichick and the Patriots organization were relentlessly scrutinized by the media and fans of the NFL. “If Belichick is the greatest coach of this generation, let’s see what he has up his sleeves for this one,” they said. The same media members who did not hesitate to write off all of Belichick’s achievements following the Spygate scandal were salivating at the prospect of a Brady-less Pats team. Brady was the heart of this football team, as evident by the Pats 0-4 preseason run, in which playing time under center was divided mostly between Matt Cassel and fellow backups Kevin O’Connell and Matt Gutierrez. It was brutal. Finally, Bill Belichick would be exposed as the cheating fraud that he is. And worse still, many Pats fans seemed to prepare for these truths to come out.
In the 2003 season, the Pats started 42 different players, an NFL record for a team that won its division. That team suffered key injuries that would have crippled most teams, yet the Pats went on to defeat Carolina in Super Bowl XXXVIII for the franchise’s second championship in three years. Belichick won the Coach of the Year award. In 2005, 45 different starters took the field and the Patriots once again won their division. Of course, neither of these teams had to deal with the loss of their star quarterback. But still, perhaps media members and fans (myself included) should not have been so quick to lose faith. Belichick always does seem to have something up his sleeve (insert bitter Spygate reference here).
But as it turned out, Brady’s injury would only get the ball rolling for the Pats medical woes. In Week 2, Laurence Maroney, the Pats leading running back from the ‘07 season, would go down as well, ultimately ending up on the Injured Reserve list after just 28 carries on the season. Second string rusher Sammy Morris also missed 3 games and received limited playing time in several others as a result of a knee injury, and third string rusher and newcomer Lamont Jordan was forced to miss 8 games with a calf injury. For several games, rushing duties were left to an undrafted back from Ole Miss named BenJarvus Green-Ellis. The football gods weren’t finished. The Pats put three-time Pro Bowl safety Rodney Harrison on the IR in Week 7 and two-time Pro Bowl linebacker Adalius Thomas on the IR in Week 10. Thomas had played 99% of all defensive snaps for the Patriots up to that point in the season. By all means, this was far too much for any team to overcome.
That’s why 11-5 and the 2008 season is simply an astonishing achievement and testament to Belichick’s coaching prowess. Certainly credit must be given to Cassel, who managed to silence all doubters and ensure a massive paycheck for himself for the next few seasons at least. But the Patriots had no business winning 11 games this season, especially in the manner that they did. Despite starting their fourth string running back for several games, the Pats finished the season with 2,278 yards rushing, the most in a single season since 1985. Furthermore, Belichick and the rest of the front office were left no choice but to reinforce its depleted linebacking corps with Rosevelt Colvin, who had been cut by the Houston Texans before the start of the season, and Junior Seau, the 39 year old veteran who went on to start a game just days after he had been surfing on the beaches of California. Colvin and Seau joined rookie linebacker Jerod Mayo, a product of draft day maneuvering by the front office and another testament to Belichick’s genius.

Over the years, a fair amount of credit has been given to Belichick’s coordinators. After the 2004 championship season, many wondered if the Patriots would be able to continue their success once coordinators Charlie Weis and Romeo Crennel left the team to pursue head coaching positions elsewhere. After the 2005 season, Crennel’s replacement, Eric Mangini, left to become the head coach of the New York Jets. While the Pats have not won a Superbowl since Weis and Crennel left, they have won their division each season except for this past one, and suffered some tough and very close playoff losses in their pursuit of another championship. On the other hand, Belichick’s coordinators have had varied success with their new positions, amassing just a single NFL playoff game and a few NCAA bowl appearances between them. Following the conclusion of the ‘08 regular season last week, both Mangini and Crennel were fired from their respective positions in New York and Cleveland. Weis is still the head coach at Notre Dame, but has a lot to prove if he wants to keep his job after next season.
With any luck, Tom Brady will be back in time to start the 2009 season and the team will return to it’s dominating form. The 2008 Matt Cassel campaign will be an aberration in the Patriots decade of dominance under Tom Brady. Yet while many Pats fans had initially hoped to block this season fully from their memories, those same fans may now see the season in a different light. Players come and go. They get injured, sign with different teams for larger contracts, retire, etc. But this season has reaffirmed for Pats fans that as long as Bill Belichick is making the calls, we’ll still have a contender to watch.
-Gabe